Field Training Test Series: Handling Drills

Wednesday, July 16, 2008

Handling Drills

Summary. In the morning at the neighborhood lacrosse field:

Series A. Handling drill (Lumi only)
Series B. Handling drill (both dogs)

Series A. MTD with no Q1/Q3, 70-50-60 yards. Time was short, and Lumi seems to need more confidence on her handling, so I just ran Lumi on this series.

Series B. MTD with no Q1/Q3, 70-50-60 yards.

Laddie's grade: B. Excellent lining, WS, casting, returns. Only problems: He dropped one dummy during a delivery, and he started chewing grass when he got to the 4th pick-up.

Lumi's grade: A-. Excellent lining, WS, returns (galloping, not trotting). Casting was accurate but sometimes hesitant. Whereas Laddie appears to view the cast as a release, Lumi seems to think about it before she responds.

In addition, Lumi slipped one whistle, when she had overrun the flag, then spotted it as she turned when I whistled. I blew WS again, insisting that she sit even though she could see the blind in front of her, then whistled come-in to the pick-up and return. I wonder whether that was the appropriate way to deal with the slipped whistle.

Building Motivation with Food. I seem to fluctuate back and forth between training with versus without food. I don't know what the right answer is with Laddie, though I suspect that food is no longer a useful reinforcer for his field training. In fact, it may well be counterproductive, leading for example to dropped articles as he anticipates the treat.

But with Lumi, I think I see it differently. Lumi has trained nearly every day of her life, often for hours per day, and for the first three years of her life, I primarily used food for reinforcement. Over the last year, it seems that each time I fade food from our field training, on the grounds that it's not helpful with Laddie's training, Lumi gradually becomes less motivated, especially on land retrieves. Then something makes me decide to bring some high value treats out, and within a few sessions, Lumi's enthusiasm improves dramatically, without any noticeable drop in quality of performance (such as dropped articles).

My tentative conclusion is that I should use treats with Lumi but not with Laddie.

3 comments:

AiSpeak said...: This comment has been removed by the author.; July 21, 2008 at 10:58 AM
AiSpeak said...: Hi, Lindsay. I noticed that too with food. Finn seems to be both food and toy motivated; with the case of retrieving, he is retrieving/play motivated. Finn holds the dummy/object and it has been our experience that working w/o a treat has been more effective in our retrieving training, retrieving itself has been a great reinforcer. But when I bring out the treat as he is coming back holding the object in his mouth, Finn comes back in front of me and drops it on my foot as soon as he sees me taking out a treat before returning heel position.

As I was assessing the situation, it made me reconsider what I was doing, maybe it would be better for me to mark it when he finishes on my left with object still in mouth... then I bring out the treat? Hmm...

Would you please illuminate the cue words you actually use for training Lumi & Laddie on the retrieving? In training Lumi (Retriever Zen video) I noticed that you use "Back" and "Give it" but what is the importance & difference of the two cues? You use "here" as the cue for recall, mark it, then let her get the treat with a high value treat.

Thank you!
~Aiko & Finnegan; July 21, 2008 at 11:35 AM
Lindsay, with Lumi & Laddie said...: A: Maybe it would be better for me to mark it when he finishes on my left with object still in mouth... then I bring out the treat?

L: Hi, Aiko. A marker, such as a click or "yes", is a secondary reinforcer, which in turn is a bridge to the primary reinforcer. But as you point out, the primary reinforcer is the retrieve itself, in this case, the next retrieve. The only reason for a marker is for precision, to make it clear to the dog what he is being reinforced for. It is an invaluable tool when needed, but you may find that Finn is equally motivated and responsive whether you use a marker of some sort in this situation or not. The same goes for the treat.

Some dogs have trouble giving up the bird. It can be so serious that it can ruin the dog's career, so if that problem starts to develop, address it quickly. Others tend to let go too soon and the article drops to the ground before you have a good grip. You can address that with a training technique I call a walk off. Please let me know if you want more detail.

A: Would you please illuminate the cue words you actually use for training Lumi & Laddie on the retrieving? In training Lumi (Retriever Zen video) I noticed that you use "Back" and "Give it" but what is the importance & difference of the two cues? You use "here" as the cue for recall, mark it, then let her get the treat with a high value treat.

L: I am still learning, and may not have used the same terminology on older videos that I'd use now. During a retrieve, I think these are the terms you'd use:

* At the line, "heel" and "here" are typically used to line the dog up.
* When the dog is lined up, "sit, mark".
* To release the dog to a mark, the dog's name, for example: "Finn".
* When the dog has the article, a whistle recall.
* To cue the dog not to drop the bird while coming to heel: "hold"
* To cue the dog to release the bird and pull his head away: "out" (some people say "give")
* To cue the dog to pick the bird back up if he drops it prematurely: "fetch" or "fetch it up". My dogs have a quirky cue for this, "give it".
* To send the dog from heel toward a blind, "back".
* To handle the dog (change his direction): whistle sit, then a cast consisting of a visual cue with arms accompanied by "back", "over", a recall whistle, or silence.
* During training but not in an event:
-- To call the dog back from an wrong initial line: "no, here". This tends to be demotivating to the dog, so it may be better to just WS and cast.
-- For a partial come in after 2-3 refused casts: "here".; July 21, 2008 at 1:47 PM

Abbreviations

2Q — two-quadrant, meaning that of the four operant conditioning quadrants, only positive reinforcement (+R) and negative punishment (-P) are used for training
4Q — four-quadrant, meaning that all four operant conditioning quadrants are used for training; in contrast to 2Q training, 4Q training also uses negative reinforcement (-R) and positive punishment (+P)
AD — Adventure Drill (click here for first of many posts on the topic, plus here and here for discussions of why it works)

BB — Bumper Boy, a remote launcher; I purchased two used BBs, the Derby Double model, in 2010 and found them an invaluable resource
BL — back line (the line you send the dog out on when you cue "back"); in the double-T drill, runs from SL, thru Q and P, to P2; Q1 and P1 are to the right, Q3 and P3 are to the left
CCD — camo canvas dummy with sewn-on orange throwing rope
CD — canvas dummy; our original canvas dummies were black and white with throwing ropes and streamers
CIW — come-in whistle; alternate abbreviation for WCI
DM — delayed mark; at one time, I invented this term to mean a poison bird (PB) that is later retrieved, but it turns out that "delayed mark" has another meaning in field sports, so I stopped using the term and switched to PB TFRL
FT — Field Trial, one of two kinds of AKC field competition
HT — Hunt Test, one of two kinds of AKC field competition
LP — lining pole
LWL, LWLW, LWLWL, etc. — land-water-land, land-water-land-water, land-water-land-water-land retrieves

OB — orange bumper, my newer terminology replacing "OD"
OD — orange dummy; eventually I added throwing ropes, which makes it much easier to carry several of them and lets me make longer happy throws, and play tug with these dummies, after the series is over
OOC — out of control, that is, not responsive to cues
P — in double-T drill, position between SL and P2 (pitcher's mound), typically nearly to P2
P1, P2, P3 — in double-T drill, positions 1 (first base), 2 (second base) and 3 (third base) when running the dog from SL (home plate)
PB — poison bird, that is, a bird that is not to be retrieved and may act as a distraction from the required marks or blinds being run; a true PB is never picked up during the series, but at times I've used the term even though I always let the dog pick the bird up after completing the other retrieves; later I began calling that a "delayed mark" (DM) rather than a PB, and when I found out that was an incorrect use of "delayed mark", I switched to PB TFRL
Q — in double-T drill, position between SL and P, typically nearly to P
Q1, Q3 — in double-T drill, positions to the right, left respectively of Q
RCD — remote casting drill, first described in the post for November 28, 2008
RL — remote launcher, used with a white streamer and a pre-positioned bird to simulate someone throwing a mark; the streamer is weighted with a carriage bolt; from the start line, the dog sees the streamer's arc when it's launched; when the dog is sent to the streamer's fall, the dog finds and retrieves the bird, having been trained to ignore the streamer and to retrieve the bird instead (see the post for November 15, 2008, for the training procedure I used)
RTP — "Ready to play?", our cue for "down" (Lumi) or "sit" (Laddie) in preparation to honor; RTP predicts that I will stand behind the dog's right flank facing toward the dog and angled away from the field, that I'll watch the dog's face until we're released, that I'll then cue Here while breaking into a run toward the van, and that we'll have a game of happy throws, parading, and tug when we get to the van; Alice suggestion I change to something that judges might find more acceptable, so I changed to "Just watch"
SM — stickman (retired gun rack with white coveralls)
SL — start line, where the handler waits after sending the dog from heel
TAL, TOL, TTL — thrown away from the line, thrown over the line, thrown toward the line of a blind in the same set-up
TFRL — thrown first, retrieved last
WCI — whistle come-in (several tweets)

WB — white bumper, my newer terminology for "WD"
WD — white dummy; ours have throwing ropes and streamers
WIL — wrong initial line on a send-out
WO — walk out, when I call "no, sit" to the dog, walk to the dog as the dog waits, then walk the dog back to the start line; also known as "picking the dog up"; because it prevents the dog from reinforcing by completing the retrieve after an incorrect response, the WO is effective in improving the dog's responsiveness to sit whistles
WS — whistle sit (a single tweet)
WSC — whistle sit and cast

TO DO List

Home

– Hold Game (Laddie)
– Focus Game (Lumi)

Solo/Land

— Hair-trigger WOs
– Interrupted series/PBs
— Hilly blinds
— Bird thrown from behind the line
– Pick-up speed drill/test
– Practice 2-seconds, "dog", 2-seconds, hand over head, 2-seconds, dog's name (2/3 of time)

– Triple blind:

>> Quick 2nd whistle for gawking (include in "The 2Q Retriever")
>> Short blinds for Lumi to build confidence
>> Bird scent irrelevancy

>> Casting into cover

– Remote retrieve and return to SL

– Heeling

Solo/Water

– Hairtrigger WOs
— Adventure Drill
— Interrupted series/PBs
— Deep LWLs
— Bird thrown from behind the line
– Set up short handling drills and call dog back to heel for slipped whistles or refused casts
– Diagonals across ditches:

>> Pile work in ditch
>> Baseball drill, where P1/P3 are the banks
>> Lining with straight and angle entries

– Rewatch Lardy video:

>> Cheaters

>> Walk-arounds

>> Chinese singles

>> Cold blinds

– On-and-off point per Woodyard article

Thrower:

— Out-of-order flyers (in a double, the flyer thrown first, then the dead bird)
— Interrupted series/PBs
— Deep LWLs
— Bird thrown from behind the line, including with a winger
– Long, unpredictable waits before sending dog on flyers
– Always practice honoring, on lead if necessary
– Try to have a blind planter during practice, so dog learns to deal with that distraction
– Get someone to act as judge: wait 3 seconds, say "dog" (quietly, like a judge); then I should wait 2-seconds, hand over head, 2-seconds, send dog
– Land and water blinds in every series if possible, with dry shots if possible

– Occasional hip-pocket and other picture drills
– Senior Hunt Test preparation:

>> Practice handling off of diversions
>> Practice walk-ups
>> Practice with line gun
>> Practice multiples with HT line mechanics, but 99% singles
>> Honoring flyers

– Master Hunt Test preparation:

>> Develop ability to handle smoothly and compliantly on a mark, and then go on to pick up the rest of the test as marks.

– L-W-L-W-L:

>> Last land
>> Intermediate point
>> Thrower on different point than fall

Training Locations

Brink — A long, narrow, heavily wooded park, several hundred yards wide and several miles long, bisected by Brink Road. A creek and a network of hiking trails run the length of the park. Except for the hiking trails, cover is usually too thick and high for training, especially during the summer when it grows chest high. The intersection of Brink Road and Wright Road, where we park on the shoulders, is about ten minutes from home.

Brook Knolls — Off MD-108. Intended as a future site for a large church, with residences on the left and the huge Olney Boys & Girls Club outdoor sports complex on the right. About 200 yards wide, several hundred yards long, but with sight lines limited because of rolling terrain. Planted as lawn, but typically overgrown from infrequent mowing. The field adjoins a busy road with no barrier, not even a rise or ditch.

Fair Hill — Off MD-108, a large new-home construction area. The grass varies from low to waist high, the ground is relatively flat but extremely uneven, and a wide variety of distractions, such as dirt mounds with kids on bikes, and large flocks of birds, are close at hand. We've used four different areas at Fair Hill for training.

Glenwood Middle School — Off MD-97 north of Brookeville, with large adjoining fields for various sports behind the school.

Laytonsville Park — A small nearby park buried among residential homes off Brink Road. The park includes a small picnic area with dozens of trees for shade, a softball field with a fence running from 1st to third base behind home plate, and a second larger field intended for soccer. The larger field is at 10 feet lower elevation and a grassy hill separates the two fields. The park's longest dimension, traversing both fields, is 240 yards with woods at either end.

Model Airpark — A 50-acre property about 10 miles from home. Click here for satellite view.

Neighborhood Lacrosse Field — An L-shaped field off East Village Avenue about five minutes from home, with a flat area approximately 100x200 yards with a baseball diamond in one corner, and an adjacent rolling field tacking on an additional 100x100 yards of lawn.

Oaks — My name for a complex of meadows between MD-108 and the Oaks Landfill, about six minutes from home. Three roughly square areas form an L-shape, and I call them Areas 1 (the largest and furthest from parking), Area 2 (the closest to MD-108), and Area 3 (the area between Areas 1 and 2, with too many trees for long retrieves but a challenging location for shorter marks and blinds). Sometimes unusable because of poor ground maintenance. Infested with ticks. A large herd of deer occupies the meadows, usually but not always staying out of sight when we train there. The meadows are also occupied by groundhogs, rodents, and birds. Occasionally, horseback riders or hikers come thru, though usually we have all three areas to ourselves. After periodic mowing, a thick layer of cut grass covers the ground, and prominent tracks from the mowing tractor tend to draw the dogs along in the direction of the tracks. Because of the many scents, irregular terrain, and thick, clumpy cover sometimes up to waist high, and various other factors, Oaks provides our most challenging training venue, making other areas including most competition venues seem easy by comparison. Click here for satellite view. Area 1 is at the north, Areas 2 and 3 are at the south separated by a line of trees and undergrowth. The center section is fenced off.

Riggs Road — A 50-acre field off Riggs Road, about ten minutes from home. The field is roughly 400x600 yards. The terrain is clumpy grass, not as smooth as a lawn but not high. The field is ringed with woods on three sides, and has what appears to be a private tractor graveyard at one end, where a residence is visible beyond the edge of the field. A "For Sale" sign hangs near the road, with an "Under Contract" notice attached. The size of the field lends itself to any number of training set-ups, but it's nearly flat and almost entirely devoid of features, with just an occasional clump of taller grass or a line of tire indentations to break up the monotony. Click here for a satellite view of the Riggs Road field.

Rolling Ridge — Acreage in a new home development off nearby Brink Road, with deeply rolling hills, several groupings of trees, a long narrow trench, and a short wide one. In wet weather, the trenches are filled with standing water and mud. The thick, clumpy grass is cut back once or twice a season, and the footing is uneven. The features provide interesting training opportunities, but the hills reduce sight lines, the footing is risky for humans as well as dogs, and residents of the surrounding homes might object if we train there too often.

Rover's Content (Cheltenham) — A field trial training property in Cheltenham, MD, owned by Milly Welsh, which she refers to as "the farm", about 50 miles and an hour's drive from home. About 100 acres, with a variety of channels, technical ponds, wetlands, ditches, mulch mounds, and large, grassy, rolling fields, surrounded by woods and dotted with trees. Buildings include a residence and a barn. Often leased by local clubs for Hunt Tests and Training Days. Most trainers, including me, usually refer to this property as "Cheltenham". Bob Hux trains here with a Hunt Test group on Tuesdays most of the year, when we usually join them. Charlie Haden runs a Field Trial group various times, including Sunday mornings, when we sometimes join them. Other times, individuals such as myself, or small groups, meet to train here for a small leasing fee. I consider it a priceless opportunity to have access to this property for training my dogs. We often arrive near dawn, train, and leave before anyone else shows up. Click here for a satellite view of the property.

Sundown Road Park — A large recreational area off Sundown Road, about five minutes from home, with lighted tennis and basketball courts, a covered picnic area, a playground, and two adjacent baseball fields. Beyond the baseball fields is a large, unmaintained meadow, with cover sometimes too high and prickly to train in.

Twin Ponds — In Monrovia, Maryland, the private estate of Rodger and Sue Armstrong, two of the leading Golden Retriever proponents in our region. As the property's name suggests, Twin Ponds includes a pair of technical ponds well suited to training and practice of water retrieves, as well as a large field with some low and some high cover that can be used for blinds.

Zion Road — A 40-acre property at the corner of MD-108 and Zion Road, about 10 minutes from home. The property has many trees, fairly widely and irregularly spaced; highly variable cover; thick clumpy grass almost everywhere; a meandering dirt road; any number of rises and dips; and miscellaneous other points of interest such as wood piles. While the fields do not appear to have any lines of sight more than 250 yards or so, they seem to present countless interesting blind opportunities up to that distance. Here's a satellite view of the property.

Archive of Training Drills

Most of the articles in this blog describe our training, but the following list of links* identifies articles that describe some particular training drills we've used.

— Alternation Drill
— Creeping Drill
— Distraction from Thrower Drill
— Double-T Drill
— Downwind Drill
— Hold Game
— Multiple Target Drill (MTD)
— Offline Drill
— Offline Drill with Keyhole
— Pick-up Speed Drill
— Recall Proofing
— Quickstop Drill
— Shore-handling Toolkit (also see article below)
— Walk-Over
— Wetfoot and Dryfoot Drills (see also Wetfoot Drill, Splash Version, with videos here and here)
— Get Your Bird
— Adventure Drill (see also this post and this post, which discuss the mechanism for this drill)
— Focus Drill
— Fork Drill

* Note: In most cases, articles posted AFTER the one linked to contain important additional information, and in some cases improved versions of the drills.

About Lindsay

Lindsay Ridgeway is a dog trainer living with Renee, the love of his life, and various other family members in Laytonsville, MD.

Lindsay trains Lumi and Laddie, his two Goldens, for field sports. His goal is to develop a protocol that enables field training to be accomplished without the use of e-collars, force fetch, and other techniques based on pressure.

Lindsay is a software developer by profession, having started his career in 1966. His other interests include taiji, endurance running, writing, and music.

About Lumi

Lumiere-du-Soleil SH WCX CGC TDI is a Golden Retriever born October 24, 2003. Her call name is "Lumi".

Prior to the spring of 2007, Lumi trained for agility, musical freestyle, and Schutzhund-style tracking, and also learned many tricks.

In various agility venues, Lumi earned seven qualifying ribbons and a number of First Places, including a double-Q at an AKC trial on July 30, 2006, in which she took First Place in both Novice events.

Since that time, Lumi has participated primarily in field sports. In summer 2007, she won First Place in the Unsteady Stake at the SMHRC Super Singles event. She then earned her GRCA Working Certificate (WC) title in September 2007, and completed her AKC Junior Hunter (JH) title in May 2008. In summer 2008, she took Third Place in her second SMHC Super Singles Unsteady Stake, and in September 2008, she earned her GRCA Working Certificate Excellent (WCX) title. In April 2010, Lumi completed her AKC Senior Hunter (SH) title, one of the first "positive-trained" dogs ever to do so.

Outside of Lumi's field work, she earned her AKC CGC title, and her TDI title, in May 2008.

Lumi has been discussed on many dog training lists, including ClickerSolutions, ClickTrain, CleanRun, and PositiveGunDogs.

In May 2005, Lindsay and Lumi started a new list called DogTrek, "Explorations in dog training". Most Internet discussions by and about Lumi now occur in that list.

Lumi, along with Laddie, were featured in the article "Hunt for Adventure" by Terry Long, in the September 2010 issue of The Whole Dog Journal.

Lumi appears in a number of videos on YouTube. Links to her YouTube playlist as well as her pedigree appear under "Links" below.

About Laddie

Topbrass Lad of the Lakes SH WCX ** is a Golden Retriever born April 22, 2007. His call name is "Laddie".

Laddie, both of whose parents were field champions, has trained for field sports since he was seven weeks old. Laddie's sire was FC AFC Emberain Beau Geste FDHF, Top Open and Amateur Golden for 2006. His dam was AFC Topbrass Pawsability.

In 2007, Laddie participated in two Puppy Stakes and won First Place in both of them. Over a nine day period in Laddie's second summer, he earned four Junior ribbons, completing his AKC Junior Hunter title on August 31, 2008. In April 2010, Laddie earned his GRCA WCX. In July 2010, Laddie earned his fourth AKC Senior Hunt Test ribbon, completing his Senior Hunter title. On April 1, 2011, Laddie, then three years old, competed in his first field trial, earning a Judge's Award of Merit (JAM) in an Owner/Handler Qualifying Stake, perhaps the first time a positive-trained retriever has ever won a ribbon in a field trial. On June 2, 2012, Laddie was awarded a Qual Reserve JAM, another first for a positive-trained retriever, and six days later, received another Qual JAM, earning ribbons in two field trials in a row, which as far as I know was also a first for a positive-trained retriever. In his next two trials, he had another JAM and another Reserve JAM, resulting in a string of four JAMs in a row, the first and last of which were Reserve JAMs. He received another JAM in his last trial of 2012, bringing his total of JAMs at that time to six with two Reserve JAMs. In May of 2013, Lindsay decided to begin running Laddie in Master Hunt Tests, and in his third Master of 2013, Laddie earned his first Master qual, perhaps the first positive-trained dog ever to receive a Master ribbon. He earned a second Master pass later in 2013, and another three in his first five Master tests of 2014, completing his Master Hunter title on May 18, 2014, perhaps the first positive-trained MH ever. Rather than continuing competition, Lindsay worked with Laddie on his lifelong behavior of vocalizing on water casts throughout the last half of 2014, then resumed running Laddie in Qualifiers in the spring of 2015, starting the season with another JAM, followed by another JAM later in the year. On September 25, 2015, Laddie earned his first field trial placement, a Third in the Colonial Qualifier, another milestone for positive-trained retrievers as far as I know.

Most Internet discussions by and about Laddie occur on the DogTrek list and PositiveGunDogs list.

Laddie, along with Lumi, were featured in the article "Hunt for Adventure" by Terry Long, in the September 2010 issue of The Whole Dog Journal.

Laddie appears in a number of videos on YouTube. Links to his YouTube playlist as well as his pedigree appear under "Links" below.

Our Most Difficult Challenges

Gun Shyness Lumi had a great fear of gunfire at first, even from hundreds of yards away. Amy Cook worked with me on the DogTrek list to use desensitization and counter-conditioning to solve the problem over a period of six weeks. It turns out that Lumi is highly birdy, so sometime later, when Lumi began to experience fliers, she became highly attracted to gunfire. I don't know if Laddie would have been gun shy in any case, but I used a simple D&CC procedure with him within the first few weeks I had him and it was never a problem.

Not Wanting to Pick Up a Bird Lumi had this problem when we first began field work, and we addressed it using a shaping procedure. She soon became quite reliable about picking birds up, and had no difficulty with her first exposure to both dead and shot fliers in a variety of species, including ducks, pheasants, pigeons, and even a Canada Goose.

Laddie had little difficulty with picking up birds at first, but later developed a reluctance to pick up some birds. We addressed that with drills that provided high-value +R for challenging retrieves.

Wanting to Eat Birds (Lumi)

Stalling at High Cover (Both dogs)

Fear of Obstructions in Water (Lumi)

Not Returning with the Article After praticing with specific difficulties such as high cover, Lumi gradually got over this problem, but it persisted with Laddie even when he had an easy return path. The problem was so serious that it seemed capable of ending his field career. We addressed it in March 2008 by starting his retrieve training over from scratch, carefully reshaping each component of the skill — the hold, the delivery, the pick-up, and so forth. It continued to be a problem at various times, such as when Laddie would pick up the article and then detour to a pond or creek in hot weather.

In Spring 2009, I invented the Adventure Drill (AD), with the idea that Laddie might be less likely to get distracted on his returns if the retrieve itself was challenging and interesting. Since the problem was only occurring in events by then, we had to wait a couple of weeks to see whether the AD was paying off, but in his last event of the spring, the problem was completely gone.

(Note. I had initially been reluctant to run Lumi on the arduous retrieves I was using for Laddie's AD, but I found that Lumi seemed to enjoy the challenge as much as Laddie, so eventually I began running both dogs on each retrieve.)

Thinking Laddie's return problem was solved after the last test of Spring 2009, I stopped working on the AD during the summer, and in Laddie's first event for Fall 2009, his returns on water retrieves were once again unsatisfactory. After a few days of training, I remembered the AD and we had one session before a pair of tests the following weekend. Though Laddie's returns were not yet as good as they had gotten in the spring, they were good enough for him to pass both tests.

Immediately thereafter, I had to begin working in New York during the work week, limited our training and in particular our AD sessions, but I continued to run AD sessions on weekends.

Land-water-land Retrieves Re-entering the water on the return with an article was a problem for Lumi for a short period, but she overcame it within a few days. By contrast, it became a major problem for Laddie at the age of one year, and we spent many sessions over the next several months addressing it. Although we put a great deal of work into it (documented in this blog), some of the major components of our efforts were:

— Teaching Laddie to alligator into the water
— Using doubles, with an LWL as the go-bird, to give Laddie something exciting to look forward to
— Firing a starter pistol as Laddie re-entered the water with the article

Recall Some of our training companions believe an unreliable recall is at the root of many of our other training issues. I don't agree on all of them — for example I don't think recall was at the heart of Laddie's LWL problems — but training a reliable recall has been one of our most demanding requirements. It's something that we work on constantly.

Slipping Whistles Both dogs have gradually developed reasonably reliable whistle sits, but the reliability requires continuous work to maintain. This blog documents the lion's share of how both dogs were trained to handle, and I feel that most if not all of the training steps we followed were indispensable. But the most striking tool, once the dogs reached a reasonably advanced level in their handling skills, has been the Walk Out.

Dropping Birds at the Start Line This has never been a problem with Lumi, but it's been an ongoing issue with Laddie. It seems to occur primarily because Laddie doesn't especially like carrying birds, compared to Lumi who does. As Laddie approaches the moment of delivery, he pushes the bird to the front of his mouth, and gives it up as quickly as possible, sometimes dropping it if I'm not ready to take it. For some time, our primary tool for dealing with it was the Walk-Away, in which I repeatedly have Laddie sit, then walk away without taking the bird and again call him to me. Another procedure that helped was reaching out with my hand and then petting Laddie's chest instead of taking the bird. Perhaps the most valuable work came later, when I began playing the Hold Game with Laddie several times a day. Click here to read a description of the Hold Game.

Breaking on Fliers Of course, steadiness was a training issue for both dogs, but access to dummies and dead birds enabled us to work on the issue and solve it for those articles fairly easily. The problem with fliers was finding opportunities to train enough with them. In the winter of early 2009, we arranged for a series of sessions when we trained extensively with various kinds of birds — pheasants, ducks, chukars — enabling us to solve the problem with live birds as well. I experimented with having the thrower interrupt the retrieve if the dog broke, but I found that the most effective solution was to have the dogs wear collars with tabs — very short leads — whenever training (so that the dogs did not develop an association between steadiness and wearing a tab), and holding the tab whenever there was any possibility of a break. I felt it was important to hold the tab in such a way that the dog could not detect whether I was holding it unless she tried to break.

In combination with that, I also trained both dogs to clearly distinguish between running a mark and honoring. When running a mark, I stand beside the dog and cue "sit, mark" before calling for the bird. When honoring, I stand at the dog's right flank so that the dog has a clear view of the field, but I face away from the field, and I cue "just watch". When released from honoring, even if my dog tried to break and I had to stop her with the tab, I then raced with her back to the van to play whatever games seemed most appealing to the particular dog, giving the dog something of high value to look forward to after being released from the honor.

Dawdling on Pick-ups Although Lumi lost her discomfort with picking birds up, and eventually came to love carrying them, she tended to revert to a behavior of turning the bird over and over, seemingly trying to select the ideal gripping position. As with slipped whistles, this behavior was most effectively addressed with Walk Outs. It was further helped by having the thrower interrupt the dog's retrieve if she dawdled, either by picking up the bird or by standing between the dog and the bird until the handler called the dog back to the SL. The advantage of having a number of throwers do this is that the dog learns that anyone nearby may interrupt the retrieve if she dawdles. I found that it needed to be done separately for fliers, since after Lumi stopped dawdling on picking up dead birds, she continued to dawdle on fliers.

Rolling during LWL Blinds. Lumi's dawdling problem deteriorated into rolling on the grass after arriving at the blind, possibly inadvertently caused or aggravated by my using WOs to discourage shaking off on the far shore. I attempted at first to use WOs to address the rolling. Some of this training is shown in videos such as this one. For a discussion of Lumi's demeanor on camera in such videos, click here. On subsequent days, I then experimented with a cheerful version of the WO, and after that with blanket cueing. Click here to read about early progress with that. Finally, I switched to the Adventure Drill, and that seemed to have the best results. Click here, here, and here for some of the many posts on the Adventure Drill.

Head-swinging. Click here to read the article "Pointed Gun Barrel for Head-Swinging".

Popping. I think that three methods we used were the most successful: For popping in water, calling Laddie back at the exact instance he turned to look at me, even if he was almost at the far shore, solved that in one session. For popping on land, I think the most valuable method I used was training with fake throws, from which Laddie learned quickly how to deal with uncertainty without popping. When he did pop, I would instantly call out "sit" and walk out to pick him up. I did not call him in, which I think would have been significantly less effective and might even have reinforced the "pop". I also heard from a friend of another method that he used successfully, but that I never tried: hiding after sending the dog so that if he popped, no one was at the start line for him to get help from.